MEETING THE ENEMY A feminist comes to terms with the Men's Rights movement | Cassie Jaye | TEDxMarin

TEDx Talks
18 Oct 201714:47
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this eye-opening account, a feminist filmmaker sets out to expose the men's rights movement, only to find herself confronting her own biases. Initially viewing the movement as misogynistic, she interviews numerous activists, later realizing the genuine issues affecting men that society often overlooks. The journey from adversary to empathizer challenges her preconceptions and calls for a more inclusive dialogue on gender equality.

Takeaways
  • 🔍 The speaker, a documentary filmmaker and feminist, decided to investigate the men's rights movement.
  • 📚 She initially believed the movement to be a misogynistic hate group based on online information.
  • 🎥 Over a year, she interviewed 44 men's rights activists (MRAs) across North America, recording their stories.
  • 👂 Despite conducting interviews, she realized she wasn't truly listening, but rather anticipating statements that confirmed her biases.
  • 🤔 Through transcribing and reviewing footage, she noticed her initial reactions to some statements were not justified.
  • 🧠 She learned to differentiate between legitimate men's issues and her own assumptions about misogyny.
  • 🔄 Her perspective evolved, recognizing that men's rights activists also support women's rights and highlight issues that disproportionately affect men.
  • 🚫 She faced backlash and protests against her film, illustrating the polarized nature of gender politics.
  • 🧩 The experience highlighted the importance of considering all sides in the gender equality debate and recognizing biases.
  • 👥 The speaker now advocates for open dialogue and listening to all voices to achieve genuine gender equality.
Q & A

  • What was the initial perception of the men's rights movement by the filmmaker?

    -The filmmaker initially perceived the men's rights movement as a misogynistic hate group actively working against women's equality, based on what she had read online.

  • What was the filmmaker's profession and background before making 'The Red Pill'?

    -The filmmaker was an award-winning documentary filmmaker and a proud feminist, with her previous work focusing on women's issues such as reproductive rights, single motherhood, and the need for more girls in STEM education.

  • How did the filmmaker's approach to interviewing change during the documentary process?

    -Initially, the filmmaker did not interrupt during interviews, but she later realized that she was not truly listening to the men's rights activists. Instead, she was anticipating and waiting to hear something that confirmed her preconceived notions.

  • What was the filmmaker's realization after reviewing and transcribing the interviews?

    -After transcribing the interviews, the filmmaker realized that her initial reactions to certain statements were not warranted, and her feeling offended did not hold up to scrutiny.

  • Can you provide an example of how the filmmaker's perspective on a men's rights activist's statement evolved?

    -One example is when a men's rights activist said that everything one sees was built by a man. Initially, the filmmaker felt this was anti-women, but later she understood it as acknowledging the unique contributions of men to society, similar to how a feminist might say everyone was birthed by a woman.

  • What was the common theme the filmmaker discovered in her video diary?

    -The common theme was that the filmmaker would often hear a valid point from a men's rights activist but would mentally add a sexist or anti-woman spin to their statements, assuming that's what they wanted to convey.

  • How did the filmmaker's understanding of domestic violence shelters change after making the film?

    -The filmmaker initially thought men's rights activists wanted to defund women's shelters, but she later understood that they were simply pointing out that men can also be victims of abuse and deserve care and compassion.

  • What was the filmmaker's initial reaction to the issue of men being falsely accused of rape?

    -Initially, the filmmaker misheard the issue as men's rights activists downplaying the severity of rape. However, she later realized they were advocating for the rights of men who were falsely accused and faced severe consequences.

  • How did the filmmaker's view on men's rights issues evolve throughout the film's production?

    -The filmmaker initially tried to insist that the issues raised by men's rights activists were actually women's issues. However, after researching and fact-checking, she acknowledged that there are many human rights issues that disproportionately or uniquely affect men.

  • What challenges did the filmmaker face after the release of 'The Red Pill'?

    -After the release, the filmmaker faced a smear campaign and protests against the film, with people who had not seen it claiming it was harmful to women. She also experienced the dehumanizing effect of humanizing her perceived enemies.

  • How did the filmmaker's identity change as a result of making 'The Red Pill'?

    -The filmmaker no longer identifies as a feminist, but she clarifies that she is not anti-feminist or a men's rights activist. She supports women's rights and now also cares about men's rights, advocating for an inclusive discussion on gender equality.

  • What advice does the filmmaker have for society regarding discussions on gender equality?

    -The filmmaker advises society to stop expecting to be offended and to start truly, openly, and sincerely listening to all voices in order to gain a greater understanding and work together towards solutions.

Outlines
00:00
🎥 Journey to Understand the Men's Rights Movement

The filmmaker, a self-identified feminist, embarked on a mission to expose the men's rights movement as a misogynistic group. Initially believing the movement to be against women's equality, she traveled across North America to interview its leaders and followers. During the interviews, she followed the rule of documentary filmmaking by not interrupting, but later realized she wasn't truly listening, as she was preoccupied with finding evidence to confirm her preconceived notions of the movement's members.

05:03
🤔 Reevaluating Prejudices and Discovering Unseen Issues

After transcribing and reviewing over 100 hours of footage, the filmmaker began to question her initial reactions. She found that her knee-jerk responses were not always justified and that her offense was not always supported by scrutiny. Through her video diary, she recognized a pattern of misinterpreting the men's rights activists' points, attributing sexist spins to their statements that were not necessarily there. She started to acknowledge the men's issues they raised, such as the disparity in domestic violence shelters and the consequences faced by men falsely accused of rape, realizing that these were valid concerns that deserved attention.

10:04
🌟 Realizing the Complexity of Gender Equality

The filmmaker's research and interactions with men's rights activists led her to understand that there are numerous issues that affect men, such as paternity fraud, selective service, workplace and war deaths, sentencing disparity, and more. She came to see that these issues are often overlooked because of the assumption that men have all the rights and privileges. Her experience taught her the importance of listening to all sides of the gender equality conversation and the need to include men's voices in the discussion.

🚫 Facing Backlash and Advocating for Open Dialogue

Upon the release of her film 'The Red Pill,' the filmmaker was met with protests and a smear campaign, as many in her community perceived humanizing the men's rights activists as harmful to women. She experienced firsthand the media's groupthink around gender politics and the dehumanizing effect of challenging the narrative. Despite this, she maintained her stance that both men's and women's rights are important and that true gender equality requires an inclusive conversation. She encourages society to listen openly and sincerely to foster understanding and work towards solutions together.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Documentary Filmmaker
A documentary filmmaker is an individual who creates non-fictional films intended to document reality, often focusing on specific social, political, or cultural issues. In the video, the speaker is an award-winning documentary filmmaker who uses this medium to explore and expose the men's rights movement, aiming to understand its perspectives and challenge her own preconceptions.
💡Feminist
A feminist is a person who advocates for the equality of the sexes, particularly in social, political, and economic matters. The speaker identifies as a proud feminist at the beginning of the video, which sets the stage for her initial bias against the men's rights movement and her journey towards a more nuanced understanding of gender issues.
💡Men's Rights Movement
The men's rights movement is a social and political movement that advocates for the rights and interests of men, often focusing on issues such as family law, domestic violence against men, and workplace safety. The speaker's initial perception of this movement as misogynistic is challenged throughout the video as she engages with its members and their concerns.
💡MRA (Men's Rights Activist)
An MRA, or men's rights activist, is someone who actively participates in the men's rights movement. The video script features interviews with various MRAs, highlighting their perspectives on issues that they believe are overlooked or unfairly treated within the broader discourse on gender equality.
💡Bias
Bias refers to a preference or inclination, often unconscious, towards one idea or group over another. The speaker acknowledges her own biases against the men's rights movement and how they influenced her initial reactions to the MRAs she interviewed, ultimately leading her to reevaluate her stance.
💡Gender Equality
Gender equality is the state of equal ease of access to resources and opportunities regardless of gender, and the absence of discrimination based on gender. The video's theme revolves around the speaker's exploration of gender equality, challenging the notion that it is a one-sided issue and advocating for a more inclusive conversation.
💡Paternity Fraud
Paternity fraud is a deception where a man is led to believe he is the biological father of a child, when he is not. The speaker mentions paternity fraud as an example of a men's issue that is uniquely affecting men and is often overlooked in discussions about gender equality.
💡Selective Service
The Selective Service in the United States refers to the system that maintains information on individuals for potential military conscription, which currently only applies to men. The speaker uses the Selective Service as an example of a policy that uniquely affects men and is part of the broader conversation on men's rights.
💡Domestic Violence
Domestic violence is a pattern of abusive behaviors by one or both partners in an intimate relationship. The video discusses the issue of domestic violence shelters, highlighting the disparity in resources available to men versus women, and the need for a more balanced approach to addressing abuse.
💡False Accusations
False accusations occur when someone is wrongly blamed or charged with a crime or wrongdoing. In the context of the video, the speaker discusses the impact of false rape accusations on men, emphasizing the importance of recognizing and addressing this issue as part of the broader conversation on gender equality.
💡Group Think
Group think is a psychological phenomenon where people in a group avoid critical evaluation or dissent due to a collective desire for conformity or harmony. The speaker describes her experience with media and public backlash as an example of group think, where her film and the issues it raised were not critically evaluated but rather dismissed due to prevailing narratives.
Highlights

In 2013, I decided to meet my enemies. I was a 27-year-old, award-winning documentary filmmaker, and a proud feminist.

I was determined to expose the dark underbelly of the men's rights movement.

At that point, all I knew of the men's rights movement was from what I'd read online: that it's a misogynistic hate group actively working against women's equality.

I spent a year traveling North America, interviewing 44 men's rights activists (MRAs) for my documentary.

While conducting my interviews, I wasn't actually listening. I was anticipating finding misogynistic statements.

A statement that initially felt anti-women: 'Just walk outside and look around, everything you see was built by a man.'

I eventually realized that my initial knee-jerk reactions to certain statements weren't really warranted.

Men's rights activists pointed out real issues such as the lack of domestic violence shelters for men and the consequences of false rape accusations.

I initially countered their points by insisting they were actually women's issues, like the custody battle discrimination against women as caretakers.

After years of researching and fact-checking, I acknowledged that there are many human rights issues that disproportionately or uniquely affect men.

Issues highlighted include paternity fraud, workplace deaths, war deaths, suicide rates, sentencing disparity, and lack of resources for male victims of domestic violence.

Men's rights activists support women's rights but ask why society doesn't care about men's rights.

The greatest challenge I faced was peeling back the layers of my own bias.

I no longer call myself a feminist, but I am not anti-feminist. I support both women's and men's rights.

If we want to honestly discuss gender equality, we need to invite all voices to the table and stop silencing men's groups.

We have to stop expecting to be offended and start truly, openly, and sincerely listening.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Thank You Divorce! | Shawn Bradford | TEDxSouthMountainCommunityLibrary

Conservatives and Progressives Debate Feminism (Extended Version)

Why domestic violence victims don't leave | Leslie Morgan Steiner | TED

Fly With Me | Full Documentary | AMERICAN EXPERIENCE | PBS

Anti & Pro Feminists Debate Abortion, Trans Rights, and #Metoo | VICE Debates

How I found out my parents were siblings, and my life changed forever

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
DocumentaryFeminismMen's RightsGender EqualityFilmmakerBiasAwarenessHuman RightsSocial IssuesMedia BiasActivism